Doth We Protest Too Little?

After interning for Morse in ’68, I served as a Philadelphia parade marshal for the half-million protesters who descended on Washington for the Peace Moratorium in 1969. The chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff characterized us as, “interminably vocal youngsters, strangers alike to soap and reason.”

On the very day alt-press publisher, Jed Morey, was covering “Occupy Wall Street” insurgents in lower Manhattan, I was taking a meet at a major bank nearby.  While an early morning text from Jed alerted me to the “Anonymous” event, the bank folks were alerting me to potential traffic jams engendered by the 66th convening of the UN General Assembly.  The NYPD so effectively contained and marginalized the protests that I had to wait on YouTube coverage to check it out.  Just as well.  Reminding the “99%” that they’re being had by the privileged 1% is a sharp message, but the rag-tag brigade from Liberty Square crying for attention aren’t the most effective messengers. (At Right – Mark Rudd, leading the takeover of Hamilton Hall at Columbia University in 1968)

My forbearers have long challenged authority and questioned conventional wisdom.  Back in 1954, with impending defeat of the French at the hands of the Viet Minh, my grandfather, an intelligence analyst with the U.S. Army, wrote, “It seems highly doubtful whether U.S. intervention would ever be able to hold Indochina.”  As he was born in western Sumatra, he had a better handle on Southeast Asia than most Americans and passed that understanding along to his off-spring. 

So it was in 1965, at age fifteen, I found myself at my first Vietnam rally in the old Madison Square Garden.  Among the keynoters, were famed baby doctor Benjamin Spock, Coretta Scott King and Senator Wayne Morse of Oregon, one of only two members of Congress to vote against the Gulf of Tonkin Resolution which Lyndon Johnson used as a blank check to escalate the conflict.  Bayard Rustin, who had organized the landmark Civil Rights march on Washington in ’63, challenged the Garden crowd of 18,000: “We must stop meeting indoors and go out into the streets.” 

A few thousand of us took up the challenge and started wending our way from 50th & 8th down through the Theatre District and over to the UN.  Filing across seedy 42nd Street in the dark of night, big, beefy red-neck types yelled, “Commies, love it or leave it!”  My 5’3” mother was accompanying me and, with a mouth that made truckers blush, dished dirtier than she got, scaring the be-Jesus out me and the red-necks too, it seemed.  It hardened me for events to come. 

After interning for Morse in ’68, I served as a Philadelphia parade marshal for the half-million protesters who descended on Washington for the Peace Moratorium in 1969.  The chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff characterized us as, “interminably vocal youngsters, strangers alike to soap and reason.”  Participants were definitely hairier than earlier peaceniks, but the DC police remained chilled, in stark contrast to the Chicago police riot at the Democratic convention the year before.

The following year I moved from protest to an “environmental teach-in,” helping to organize the first Earth Week.  We drew support from across the board with some sixty corporate sponsors such as GE, Rohm&Hass, Scott Paper and Bell Tel.  At the feel-good culmination in Phillie’s Fairmont Park, Senator Ed Muskie, sponsor of the landmark Clean Air Act of 1970 delivered the keynote and the cast of “Hair” sang “Hello Carbon Monoxide.”  By the end of the year, Richard Nixon, perhaps as a tactical diversion from other deeds, created the Environmental Protection Agency.

Right now, if you go around the country,” Tom Steyer said upon receiving the 2011 Rage for Justice Award, “the fight is about the right of the Environmental Protection Agency to protect the environment.”  Rage for Justice Award is not brought to us by the Day of Rage folks who Occupied Wall Street but from Consumer Watchdog who “expose rip-offs and injustice.”  And Tom Steyer is not your usual activist, but a billionaire hedge fund manager.  He received the award in recognition of facing down the gas-producing Koch brothers and their Texas oil brethren who attempted, in 2010, with Proposition 23, to overturn AB 32 that has turned California into the beacon of the clean energy economy.

“They we’re in a situation where they [Koch bros] were going to make a bet about protecting their bottom line,” Steyer said.  “So it was always a risk/reward bet the way businesses work.  So if they started to get behind that meant that the risks were higher and the reward less likely to pursue the fight.  So that, in a funny way, it’s like being in a fight with a bully.  You know that if you can ever get him scared, he’ll quit.

 “We view the environmental fight as something where the message is really important and the messenger is really important.  We believe that if people are going to understand it, they are not only going to have to hear something true, they’re going to have hear it from someone they trust.”

In the battle against Prop 23, Steyer was aligned with former Marine captain George Schultz who held four cabinet posts under Nixon and Reagan.  In the posturing over tax misrepresentation, Obama finally invoked Warren Buffet’s year-old call to tax the very rich.  While guerilla street theater can be tippingly pointed, establishment messengers of principle will likely gain far more traction in today’s America.  Which is why this 60s organizer found himself at a big bank during the Occupation of Wall Street looking for ways to make energy efficiency pencil out.

Author: Dorian Dale

Dorian Dale’s writing has appeared in journals ranging from Government Security News to Dads World. He is the 8th Distinguished Citi Fellow at the NYU’s Stern School of Business and a member of the Associations of Old Crows and Former Intelligence Officers. Submissions fielded at doriandale@aol.com

10 thoughts on “Doth We Protest Too Little?”

  1. Not sure how I feel about this, my friend. I think the brilliance of Occupy Wall Street is that they’re raising awareness about several issues by not having one single issue. Chief organizer “Anonymous” is allowing the people to give voice to our collective dis-ease and unrest and granting ownership to all… Furthermore, they’re in the belly of the beast. Your experience tells you to chip away from the inside but that’s just because you know where to enter. What should our disenfranchised youth do from the outside looking in?

  2. “Reminding the “99%” that they’re being had by the privileged 1% is a sharp message, but the rag-tag brigade from Liberty Square crying for attention aren’t the most effective messengers.” I was in lower Manhattan this weekend for the Tunnel to Towers Run, checked out the “occupation,” and frankly had the same reaction. After too many nights, sleeping out in the elements, the group probably appears more “rag-tag” than on day one of the protest, but I was left wondering whether the average person would connect with the messengers. Not a chance. They are too easily dismissed and relegated to the “protester” stereotype. Passerby reactions ranged from fear to disgust to amusement as phrases like “corporate elite” dribbled out of a static-filled megaphone. These folks were easily marginalized and I suspect, their message was lost. Indeed, we need more protests in order to revitalize our democracy, but the “we” doing the protesting needs a broader cross-section of folks if we are to truly connect with more of that 99%.

  3. By trecking my trajectory from teen to geezer, I was illustrating that there are several ways to skin a cat.
    I rated Occupy Wall Street “tippingly pointed,” though not brilliant, as you express. It’s hard to fathom whether it’s impacting the collective unconsciousness or is merely cathartic and preaching to the choir.

  4. Putin just sold Exxon access to the Russian arctic. Hydro carbons REPORTED valued at 500billion. Will getting arrested build a better energy infrastructure?

    Rather, policy and investment have to get synched (synchronized) to build efficient-ecologic infrastructure. More and more people working on the ecologic synch.

    Otherwise, things look extra messy going forward.

  5. The problem is the lack of consequences, Vietnam got the attention because you could be the next one getting shot,the economy ,even at its lowest point,did not create bread lines and very few have experienced real hardship. The young crowd that protested wall street did not have an alternate solution, after we close Wall Street what? The answer is the anathema of American politics, a reform that is Socialist in its nature.How many Americans would follow?

  6. Reading this made me think that, in this age of FlashMobs and Talking Animal videos, that there might be new, more effective mechanisms for product boycott by leveraging the Internet. I’m surprised I haven’t seen many to-date. In theory, product boycott should work, applying targeted pressure to commerce, but the sustainability and organized mass communication appears to always have faltered in the past. The Internet through social media seems to have largely solved this. Despite the failure of my 6-year personal boycott to bring down Mobil/Exxon, I feel this could have new legs….

  7. Leon, Leon, you need to know that your efforts held the market cap of ExxonMobil flat for the past five years, so take heart and lay your FlashMobbing on them!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *